Introduction

Mystery anthologies continue to captivate readers in 2025, offering collections of thrilling stories from both established and emerging authors. These compilations provide the perfect opportunity to experience various writing styles and storytelling approaches all within a single volume. From cozy mysteries to supernatural thrillers, the best-selling collections and anthologies in the mystery genre showcase diverse narratives that explore the darker side of human nature while celebrating the art of detective work and puzzle-solving. Whether you're looking for classic whodunits or contemporary mysteries with a twist, these top-selling anthologies on Amazon offer something for every mystery enthusiast.

What Makes Collections & Anthologies So Compelling

Mystery anthologies appeal to readers for several compelling reasons. First, they provide a sampler of different authors' writing styles, allowing readers to discover new favorite mystery writers without committing to full-length novels. Additionally, the shorter format of stories in anthologies creates a perfect reading experience for busy lifestyles, offering complete mysteries that can be enjoyed during commutes or brief reading sessions. Anthologies also allow for more experimental approaches to the mystery genre, with authors often pushing boundaries they might not explore in their longer works. Finally, collections centered around specific themes or featuring beloved recurring characters provide depth and variety that single-author novels cannot match. This combination of accessibility, variety, and quality storytelling explains why mystery anthologies remain perennial favorites among readers.

The Current Top 10 Best-Selling Collections & Anthologies on Amazon

1. Mystery Writers of America Presents The Rich and the Dead by Mystery Writers of America Inc.

Selected by acclaimed thriller author Nelson DeMille, this anthology brings together some of the finest mystery writers to explore crime among society's elite. Each story delves into the dark underbelly of wealth and privilege, showcasing how the ultra-rich approach wrongdoing with the same extravagance they bring to their businesses, mansions, and vacations.

With tales ranging from a wealthy writer plotting against his agent to a spoiled rich boy's dangerous antics, this collection offers readers a glimpse behind the curtain of the lives of those who control most of the world's wealth. The anthology expertly balances suspense with social commentary, making it the top-selling mystery collection of 2025.

Buy Now

2. Tiffany Black Cozy Mystery Compilation Books 1 to 12 by A.R. Winters

This comprehensive box set follows cupcake-loving croupier Tiffany Black as she transitions from dealing cards to solving crimes as a private investigator. Set against the vibrant backdrop of Las Vegas, these twelve mysteries combine fast-paced sleuthing with laugh-out-loud humor and a dash of romance that keeps readers coming back for more.

What makes this collection stand out is Tiffany's lovable, relatable character with her sweet tooth and determination, balanced by a colorful supporting cast including her poker-hustling Nanna. With over 2,000 pages of mystery solving and jaw-dropping twists, this compilation offers exceptional value for cozy mystery fans.

Buy Now

3. Paws & Poltergeists Mysteries Complete: Books 1-8 by Mara Webb

This unique paranormal mystery collection follows a woman sentenced to community service who finds herself serving the most unusual community of all—the dead. With her childhood dog Fluke mysteriously returned to help her investigate, she must navigate the supernatural elements of Silverwood while solving a string of mysterious deaths.

Webb masterfully combines paranormal elements with classic mystery tropes, creating a series that's both familiar and refreshingly original. With over 1,000 pages of ghostly investigations and canine companionship, this complete series boxset has quickly become a favorite among readers who enjoy their mysteries with a supernatural twist.

Buy Now

4. Sweet Tea Witch Mysteries Books 1-10: Hysterical Southern Cozy Mysteries by Amy Boyles

Following the misadventures of Pepper Dunn, this magical mystery collection combines Southern charm with witchy wonder. After losing everything in a single day, Pepper discovers she's a witch who has inherited the most important store in the magical town of Magnolia Cove, Alabama—a pet shop, despite her dislike for animals.

What distinguishes this anthology is its perfect blend of humor, magic, and mystery, all wrapped in authentic Southern hospitality. Readers are drawn to the quirky characters, including a traumatized talking cat, a mysterious private detective, and Pepper's shotgun-wielding grandmother with her strict curfew. With ten full-length novels totaling 2,000 pages, this collection delivers exceptional value and entertainment.

Buy Now

5. Partners in Crime (Tommy & Tuppence) by Agatha Christie

This classic collection from the Queen of Crime features the charming and adventurous newlyweds Tommy and Tuppence Beresford as they take over the International Detective Agency. Christie's beloved duo channels techniques from fictional sleuths like Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot while adding their own unique cleverness to solve a variety of intriguing cases.

What makes this anthology timeless is Christie's expert blend of humor and mystery, along with the delightful chemistry between the protagonist couple. From government spies to country house thieves and costume ball murderers, the variety of mysteries keeps readers engaged while showcasing Christie's masterful plotting that continues to captivate new generations of mystery lovers.

Buy Now

6. Spellcaster Creek Witch Mysteries Complete: Books 1-10 by Mara Webb

This enchanting collection follows Sage Rivers, who discovers she's a witch after losing everything in a single day. As a book witch who sees spirits whenever she touches books, Sage finds herself embroiled in a murder investigation shortly after inheriting a bookshop in the magical town of Spellcaster Creek.

Webb's second entry in the top ten showcases her talent for blending paranormal elements with classic mystery structures. The unique magical system where Sage interacts with spirits through books provides a fresh angle on the witch mystery subgenre. With ten complete novels totaling over 1,300 pages, this boxset offers tremendous value for readers who enjoy their mysteries with magical elements.

Buy Now

7. Pelican Cove Cozy Mystery Series Box Set 1: Books 1-4 by Leena Clover

This delightful culinary mystery collection follows recently divorced baker Jenny King as she navigates a new life on a remote island. Working at the Boardwalk Cafe, Jenny finds herself investigating a murder when her aunt is arrested after a body washes up on the beach, leading her to follow a trail of clues while serving cakes and muffins with a smile.

What sets this anthology apart is its perfect blend of beach setting, mouthwatering baked goods, and engaging mysteries. The friendship between Jenny and her allies, the Magnolias, adds warmth to the series, while the idyllic small-town setting provides a charming backdrop for murder investigations. With recipes included throughout, this collection satisfies both culinary and mystery cravings.

Buy Now

8. The Murder at the Vicarage: A Miss Marple Mystery by Agatha Christie

Christie's masterful introduction to her beloved sleuth Miss Marple continues to captivate contemporary readers. Set in the seemingly peaceful village of St. Mary Mead, this mystery revolves around the murder of the universally detested Colonel Protheroe, who is found shot in the vicar's study with a host of potential suspects.

Though not an anthology in the traditional sense, this novel established the pattern for the subsequent Miss Marple series, which collectively forms one of mystery's most enduring collections. Christie's genius lies in her creation of a seemingly innocuous elderly woman whose deep understanding of human nature makes her an exceptional detective. This foundational work remains essential reading for any mystery enthusiast.

Buy Now

9. Pendle Island Witch Mysteries Complete Books 1-12 by Mara Webb

Webb's third entry in our top ten follows Chelsea Moon as she returns to her birthplace of Pendle Island seeking a vacation, only to discover she's a witch and her recently deceased Great Aunt Griselda was murdered. As the sole heir to Griselda's estate, Chelsea inherits a haunted house complete with a pirate ghost, a talking cat, and mysterious neighbors.

This collection stands out for its intricate world-building and engaging character development. Webb expertly balances supernatural elements with classic murder mystery tropes while exploring themes of family legacy and self-discovery. With twelve complete novels spanning over 1,700 pages, this comprehensive boxset provides excellent value and has become a favorite among paranormal mystery enthusiasts.

Buy Now

10. Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries Complete: Books 1-15 by Mara Webb

Webb's fourth and final entry in our top ten follows café owner Sadie Alden as she relocates to a remote island for a fresh start. Upon arrival at Hallow Haven, she discovers the locals know secrets about her that even she doesn't know, including her witch heritage. When a storm uncovers a mysterious grave, Sadie finds herself drawn into island mysteries both ancient and personal.

The beachside setting combined with witchcraft and local feuds creates a uniquely atmospheric backdrop for these mysteries. Webb excels at building complex magical systems while maintaining the classic elements that mystery readers love. With fifteen complete novels totaling over 1,800 pages, this massive collection represents the best value on our list and concludes our roundup of 2025's best-selling mystery anthologies.

Buy Now