Best-Selling Women Sleuth Mystery Novels in 2025
1. 25 Alive: A Women's Murder Club Thriller by James Patterson
In this milestone installment of Patterson's enduring Women's Murder Club series, the team faces their most personal case yet—investigating the shocking murder of Warren Jacobi, Lindsay Boxer's former partner who rose to become San Francisco's chief of police. The crime scene in Golden Gate Park presents veteran homicide detective Boxer with the devastating task of solving the murder of her mentor and friend.
What makes this entry particularly compelling is how it leverages the established dynamics between the four women investigators—Sergeant Lindsay Boxer, medical examiner Claire Washburn, Assistant District Attorney Yuki Castellano, and crime reporter Cindy Thomas—as they pursue justice for one of their own. Patterson expertly balances their professional determination with personal grief as they follow a trail of evidence down the west coast, racing to prevent the killer from targeting another member of their inner circle.
Buy Now2. The Frozen River: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel by Ariel Lawhon
Set in late 18th-century Maine, Lawhon's historical mystery introduces readers to Martha Ballard, a midwife and healer who becomes an unlikely detective when a man's body is discovered frozen in the Kennebec River. Despite a local physician dismissing the death as accidental, Martha's examination leads her to suspect murder—a conclusion that puts her at odds with the town's respected gentlemen, some of whom she had previously documented as perpetrators of an alleged rape.
What distinguishes this novel is its basis in the real-life diary of Martha Ballard, a historical figure who meticulously recorded births, deaths, and crimes in her community. Lawhon crafts a compelling portrait of a woman who must navigate the constraints of her time while pursuing justice, using her unique position as a midwife—with access to private homes and intimate knowledge of the community's secrets—to investigate a case that threatens to implicate those closest to her. The tension between Martha's determination to uncover truth and the social forces aligned against her creates a mystery that's as much about gender politics as it is about solving a crime.
Buy Now3. Listen for the Lie: A Novel by Amy Tintera
Tintera turns the traditional detective narrative on its head with this psychological thriller about Lucy, a woman who might have murdered her best friend Savvy—a night she cannot remember—and who now returns to her small Texas hometown to investigate the truth after a popular true crime podcast decides to feature the case. The unique twist of having a protagonist who may be both detective and perpetrator creates a compelling tension as Lucy searches for answers about what happened that fateful night.
What makes "Listen for the Lie" stand out is its exploration of modern true crime culture and its impact on real-world cases. Through the character of podcast host Ben Owens and the media sensation surrounding Savvy's murder, Tintera examines how narratives are constructed and how public perception influences justice. The novel masterfully balances Lucy's personal investigation—fueled by genuine uncertainty about her own actions—with broader questions about truth, memory, and how stories about women are told and consumed in contemporary society.
Buy Now4. Heartwood (A Read with Jenna Pick): A Novel by Amity Gaige
Gaige's "Heartwood" presents a multi-perspective mystery centered on the disappearance of forty-two-year-old Valerie Gillis on the Appalachian Trail in Maine. The novel weaves together three distinct female viewpoints: Valerie herself, through poetic letters written to her mother as she struggles to survive; Beverly, the determined Maine State Game Warden leading the ground search; and Lena, a seventy-six-year-old birdwatcher who becomes an unexpected "armchair detective" from her Connecticut retirement community.
What distinguishes this wilderness mystery is its exploration of different investigative approaches across generations and circumstances. While Beverly represents traditional law enforcement methodology, Lena's distant analysis demonstrates how keen observation and life experience can provide crucial insights even from afar. The novel delves into the psychological dimensions of being lost—both literally for Valerie and figuratively for all three women—creating a mystery that's as much about internal journeys as it is about the physical search. As suspicions grow that Valerie's disappearance may not be accidental, the narrative transforms from survival story to complex mystery with themes of redemption and self-discovery.
Buy Now5. The 24th Hour: A Women's Murder Club Thriller by James Patterson
Patterson delivers another fast-paced entry in his Women's Murder Club series, opening with what should be a joyous occasion—celebration of Cindy Thomas's engagement—that quickly turns into a complex investigation when a woman is assaulted at the restaurant where they're dining. The four friends immediately shift into their professional roles: Claire examines the victim, Lindsay makes an arrest, Yuki prosecutes, and Cindy covers the story as a crime reporter.
What makes this installment particularly intriguing is how it parallels two investigations: the assault case with its complicated legal challenges due to the victim's changing testimony, and a high-society murder investigation that threatens the Women's Murder Club directly. Patterson expertly showcases each woman's professional expertise while highlighting their personal vulnerabilities as they race against time to solve both cases before Cindy's wedding. The novel demonstrates why this team of professional women investigators continues to captivate readers—their combination of specialized skills creates a formidable investigative force when working together.
Buy Now6. 2 Sisters Murder Investigations: A Thriller by James Patterson
Patterson introduces a fresh detective duo with the Bird sisters—Rhonda, a methodical former attorney who approaches investigations by the book, and her teenage half-sister Barbara ("Baby"), who relies on street smarts and intuition. Despite their opposing personalities and investigative methods, they've established a detective agency in Los Angeles where their first major case involves a controversial client whose popular wife has gone missing.
What distinguishes this entry in the women sleuth genre is the dynamic between sisters who share little except a late father and a determination to discover truth. Their contrasting approaches to investigation—Rhonda's legal precision versus Baby's improvisational style—create both conflict and complementary strengths as they navigate a case where public opinion has already condemned their client. Patterson leverages their sisterly friction to explore how different investigative methods can reveal different aspects of a case, while their shared commitment to justice ultimately provides the common ground they need to work effectively together.
Buy Now7. She Came Back: A Miss Silver Mystery Series, Book 9 by Patricia Wentworth
In this classic mystery set in World War II-era England, beloved governess-turned-detective Miss Maud Silver faces an intriguing case when a woman claiming to be Anne Jocelyn returns three years after supposedly being killed while escaping German-occupied France. Anne's husband, Phillip, who personally buried what he believed was his wife's body, is convinced this woman is an impostor seeking to claim Anne's wealth, setting up a compelling question of identity and deception.
What makes Wentworth's Miss Silver novels endure—with this title enjoying renewed popularity in 2025—is the protagonist's unassuming appearance that belies her shrewd intellect. As a former governess, Miss Silver leverages her observational skills, understanding of human nature, and social position to gather information that conventional investigators might miss. The wartime setting adds layers of complexity to questions of identity and truth, as displacement, trauma, and opportunity for deception abound. This mystery showcases how a seemingly unremarkable older woman can become an exceptional detective through patience, perception, and psychological insight.
Buy Now8. The Missing Half: A Novel by Ashley Flowers
From true crime podcast host Ashley Flowers comes this compelling mystery where two women—Nicole "Nic" Monroe and Jenna Connor—team up to investigate the seemingly connected cold cases of their missing sisters. Seven years after Nic's sister Kasey vanished, leaving only her abandoned car over a hundred miles from home, Jenna Connor enters Nic's life with information about her own sister Jules, who disappeared in the same mysterious manner just two weeks before Kasey.
What makes "The Missing Half" stand out is its exploration of how grief and loss transform ordinary women into determined investigators when conventional authorities have given up. Drawing on her expertise in true crime analysis, Flowers creates amateur sleuths whose personal stakes drive them to uncover leads professionals overlooked, while their sibling bonds to the victims provide emotional resonance and insider knowledge. The novel powerfully examines how sisters who lost "their other halves" form an investigative partnership where their shared loss becomes their greatest strength, even as their pursuit of truth threatens to unravel everything they thought they knew about their families.
Buy Now9. The Girl Who Takes an Eye for an Eye: A Lisbeth Salander novel by David Lagercrantz
In this continuation of Stieg Larsson's Millennium series, the iconic hacker-investigator Lisbeth Salander embarks on a mission to uncover the secrets of her mysterious past while confronting multiple threats. Despite being incarcerated, Lisbeth's determination to expose the truth about a sinister pseudoscientific experiment known as "The Registry" leads her to collaborate once again with journalist Mikael Blomkvist, forming an investigative partnership that has defined the series.
What continues to make Lisbeth Salander one of the most compelling women sleuths in contemporary fiction is her uncompromising pursuit of justice on her own terms. Unlike conventional detectives, Lisbeth operates outside social norms and legal boundaries, using her extraordinary hacking skills and willingness to confront violence with violence when necessary. This installment particularly showcases her resilience as she simultaneously battles prison gang leaders, Islamic extremists, and her own long-lost twin sister Camilla while untangling the conspiracy that shaped her childhood. Lagercrantz maintains the series' hallmark exploration of institutional corruption and social injustice through a protagonist who embodies both victimhood and fierce resistance.
Buy Now10. None of This Is True: A Novel by Lisa Jewell
Jewell's psychological thriller cleverly inverts the typical investigative narrative by transforming podcaster Alix Summer from storyteller to subject when she becomes entangled with Josie Fair, a woman who shares her birthday and gradually infiltrates her life before mysteriously disappearing. The story shifts from Alix creating content about others to becoming the reluctant protagonist of her own true crime podcast as she discovers Josie has left behind a dangerous legacy that threatens Alix and her family.
What makes "None of This Is True" a standout in the women sleuth genre is its exploration of how modern media blurs the lines between investigator and investigated. Alix must rapidly evolve from professional observer to active detective as she races to uncover Josie's true identity and motives before the threats against her family materialize. Jewell examines the vulnerability that comes with public visibility and how a woman who made her career documenting others' stories must now investigate the most personal case of all—one where she failed to see the danger until it was embedded in her own life. The novel's tension derives from this role reversal, creating a protagonist who must develop investigative skills under the most threatening circumstances.
Buy Now